Skip to main content

The Odyssey of Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark, A Problem of Culture?

With a new Venom comic debuting today, and Spider-Man featured in the new FF: Future Foundation comic, I'm taking a moment to reflect on Spider-Man's live action effort on Broadway. The recent critical thrashing of Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark is more than the story of a troubled Broadway show. As any number of Broadway professionals can tell you, many shows have been marked by soaring budgets, deep-pocketed backers, and mercurial creative minds coming to a sad end. Indeed, other rock musicals, Jesus Christ Superstar and Hair prime examples, faced similar problems. Yet, few have received the rancorous focus associated with this comic book-inspired show. Even before the critical onslaught, the cultural fixation on Spider-Man: TOD was severe. Spider-Man: TOD is a natural target for unfavorable scrutiny in part because it is about Spider-Man.

This to me is the core issue. Spider-Man: TOD has generated so much press because unlike other dubious productions, Spider-Man: TOD embodies the contemporary tension between an insurgent populist attitude and highbrow cultural merit. Consider this strange point of pop culture truth: while critical appraisal has been negative from the beginning, Glenn Beck and Oprah Winfrey urged their respective audiences to embrace the production. As icons from radically different segments of the populist media landscape, their endorsements promised an eager audience. Indeed, even now Spider-Man: TOD is outselling critical darlings such as Wicked.

The problems facing Spider-Man: TOD should be understood within the context of superhero comics that gave it birth. Comic books have always been dogged by a marginal status. Defined as cheap distraction for the masses in the 1940s, they were blamed for juvenile delinquency in 1950s. Spider-Man’s debut in the 1960s did not redeem the genre. Marvel Comics’ popularity coincided with a youth counterculture that splintered society into a subversive underground versus a traditional mainstream. The fact that Spider-Man, the quintessential angst-ridden teenage superhero, is the subject of the most expensive Broadway production in history is the latest triumph of a medium known more for the power of adolescent fantasy than artistry.

The reaction against the show naturally grows from the tinge of pulp crassness linked to comics. While the “graphic novel” offers the opportunity for artistic endeavor, superhero comics are still immature. The schism is a cultural quirk, but an important truth. Even as the comic medium has grown to encompass every literary genre, the superhero remains its dominant iconic face. Idyllic and fantastic, the superhero endures and expands, fueling multibillion-dollar corporate media giants. At some level, the superhero on film is an acceptable addition to mass medium common appeal. In contrast, theatre remains a bastion of elite culture. The accepted Broadway turn to add substance to actor’s resume highlights the “Great White Way” continued gravitas. It is not surprising that a Broadway Spider Man show has drawn critical scrutiny and popular anticipation. Spiderman's quest to live up to the responsibility obligated by his power is evocative of the myriad populist reactions (everything from MoveOn.org to the Tea Party) aimed at “saving” the country. Spider-Man: TOD is not a comical farce poking fun at the excesses of the superhero archetype, but a celebration of the power represented by it. Like the comics that spawned it, cultural arbiters question the colorful display and cultural merit, but for all its excesses, the show, like the superhero, embodies values and beliefs that define the U.S. experience.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Mythology and Superheroes in Comics

Ohhh my goodness... When I decided on trying to analyze the mythological origins and references in superhero comics, I had no idea the can of worms I was opening up... On the one hand, it was awesome to see just how many connections there were between superheroes and psychology/mythology/philosophy, but all the information also made it terribly difficult to distinguish what I should be using and how to tie it all together. When I was talking to one of my sorority sisters about it she said, "Oh yeah, well, research essays are kind of like putting together puzzles..." and I think that really sums up what writing this paper was like for me. Fortunately, I was really interested throughout the whole process and I very much enjoyed writing the paper. Being a psychology major, I was especially interested in reading about the Jungian archetypes that had a lot of parallels with major modern comic books superheroes. I was also able to incorporate Joseph Campbell's "hero cycle&

Why blame comics for societal failure?

Why blame comics for societal failure? Society blamed comics for the societal failures because it was a fairly new industry, and as things seemed to go “wrong” they figured it must be comic books. When a child grew up during the war, his father was probably killing people and the military and his mother was probably making things in factories to help kill the opposition. The only things kids had to “babysit” them was comic books, and they read many different kinds. So when kids starting acting differently in this new generation the figured it must be the comic books. Society didn’t want to believe it may have been the internal and external scars war causes on the soldiers and their families. Also the fact that young unattended children are reading these comics may not be able to differentiate between fantasy and reality. When society fails it always needs a scapegoat then it was comic books next it was rock and roll. Society naturally resist change.

#FUTURES: Tomorrow Idris Elba will be the Last Man Standing

There is some bad buzz around Pacific Rim on the web. I suspect the possibility of a giant robot movie being awesome is too much for some people.  The internet is full of dark corners, but until we see the movie we won't know the box office.  What we can tell right now is that Idris Elba is doing his part to make the movie a success. A standout performer, Elba has made a name for himself in countless productions .  He achieve wide recognition for his turn on the big screen in films such as Thor and on the small screen in the BBC's Luther . Of course, the open question about actors of color in any film is whether not they will help or hurt the box office.  Will Smith recent disappointment with After Earth opens the door for this conversation. His lack of success sparks the question who will be the next "bankable" star of color. There can be only one! See what I did there:-)  These sentiments reflect a Hollywood centric approach that ignores Nollywood