Skip to main content

How have we changed our definition of the comic form over time?

At its essence, I believe our definition of the actual comic form has changed very little over time. Whether dime novels or pulp fictions or comic books and strips, the image that comes to mind is a story, typically told through both text and picture, that depicts a hero struggling against the greatest fears of contemporary society. While artistic styles, color technology, and even the icons used to depict these stories may change over time, the iconic format of the comic itself remains the same. What changes is the message portrayed though the story. This message always speaks to what society's greatest fear is, as it is this fear that the hero must struggle against and, inevitably, overcome. In America, the comic form has a history of presenting the national ideal of an individual and upholding what are viewed as societal values and identities. These then overcome any perceived threats to this national self-image, threats which change depending on the time.

In terms of content, the comic form was first found among the dime novels, the country was undergoing rapid urbanization in the post-Civil War era, and the western frontier was nearly, if not already, extinct. The sense of American identity, which to that point had been inseparable from "Manifest Destiny", underwent an identity crisis. Along with this closing of the frontier came urbanization and a massive influx of immigration. Many people feared that these things would combine to degrade civilization and the American way of life. In answer to this was the dime novels of popular culture, which often featured men who were the best of what society had to offer overcoming adverse conditions or enemies to behave in a way representative of American virtues. When the Great Depression introduced into the common mind the idea that living according to these virtues might not be enough to succeed for normal humans, superheroes were introduced as the more-than-ordinary individuals required to overcome the days adversity. Thus, the identity of the modern comic was born.

While the evolution of how the content of comics formed plays a key role in the view of comics today, the development of the physical format is equally important. Comic books emerged from the hybridization of comic strips and pulp fiction. While pulp fiction may have provided the basis for the fantastical stories, the comic strips are what gave rise to the combination of text and illustrations in sequential panels to tell a tale. Comic strips originated as weekly installments used to attract readers. Then they began to be issued in a compilation book format. Eventually, publishers began seeking new materials to sell in the books, not just reprints of old comics. Taking the idea material from pulp fiction, they applied to formatting of the comic strips. In this way, comic books in their familiar format developed.

Comments

J Chambliss said…
I think you have touched on a key point. Does the medium change or the message. At some level, scholars argue that comics are merely the current form of communal narrative. These stories have not changed, merely the means to tell them.

Popular posts from this blog

Understanding Comics Ch. 1-2 & Comic Book Nation Ch.1

To begin with, I really do like the idea of reading a comic about comics. I think it's a great idea and it's very well executed. As I was reading the first two chapters, I was surprised at how many examples there were of art in recent (and ancient, in some cases) history that are variations of "sequential visual art" and thus the foundations of modern comics. I'd never even thought about it before and it was hard to believe how many different kinds there were. I also love all the discussion about how our human brains automatically interpret certain images in a specific way, how we see others constantly but we identify ourselves when we look at cartoons, and how inanimate objects automatically becomes extensions of our bodies. The pyramid of styles was very interesting too as a way to conceptualize and almost graph or "place" a specific art style in comics. In Comic Book Nation , I enjoyed reading about the evolution of early comics from "funnies...

MegaCon 2011 Mobile Blog Entry

Next up, the Crime Noir Panel hosted by The Rack Pack Comic Podcast . Jimmy Palmiotti, Frank Tieri, Darwyn Cook and Dave Johnson are the speakers. MegaCon has matured as the comic industry has grown in importance in popular culture. Orlando's native convention should be attracting this kind of top talents and now it seem to be doing it.

Truth, Justice, and the American Way!

Look- in the sky! It's a bird! It's a plane! It's... SUPERMAN!!! Look- in that room! It's a cat! It's a giant lump! It's me... BORED! I have never quite been able to assess why I dislike Superman so much. He's supposedly the purest, truest American superhero we have. America's very own mythology. And I like America well enough, some might even say I love it. So why do I dislike Superman so much. Maybe it's because he doesn't feel truly American to me. I mean, don't get me wrong- he's all about truth and justice and all. He's an immigrant of sorts, and he definitely falls into the whole perfect body image paradigm. But he's not flawed, and less face it, all Americans are flawed... most time really REALLY flawed. Iron Man's an alcoholic, Spider-Man's a brooding, angsty "I caused the death of my first, possibly true, love" young adult, and the X-men are all mutant 'freaks' (note these are all Marvel comics)....